Ferguson v. JONAH – Documents

Ferguson v. JONAH, L-5473-12
Superior Court of New Jersey, Hudson County, Law Division
Assigned to: Judge Peter F. Bariso, Jr.

Complaint and Answers

• Complaint filed by Plaintiffs Michael Ferguson, et al. (“Plaintiffs”) (11/27/2013)
  • Answer filed by Defendants JONAH, et al. (“Defendants”) (02/04/2013)
  • Amended Answer filed by Defendants [adding additional affirmative defenses] (03/04/2013)

Case Management Orders

• Initial Management Order  (03/06/2013)

Defendants’ Motions to Quash Subpoenas for Production of Evidence

• Motion as to Shamash Listserv Mailing List Manager and David Rosenthal (04/12/2013)
  • Notice and [Proposed] Order
  • In Support:
    • Memo
    • Certification of Charles S. LiMandri
    • Certification of Arthur Goldberg
• ORDER Granting in part (06/07/2013)

• Motion as to Thaddeus Heffner (04/12/2013)
  • Notice and [Proposed] Order
  • In Support:
    • Memo
    • Certification of Charles S. LiMandri
    • Certification of Thaddeus Heffner

Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss

• Defendants’ Brief (05/29/2013)
  • Certifications:
    • Charles LiMandri:  Part 1 and Part 2
    • Michelle A. Cretella, M.D.
    • Nicholas A. Cummings, Ph.D., Sc.D.
• Plaintiffs’ Opposition (07/11/2013)
• Defendants’ Reply (07/15/2013)
• ORDER Denying Motion (07/19/13)

Plaintiffs’ Motion to Compel (Produce Documents)

• Motion to compel Defendants’ Compliance with June 7 order (07/18/2013)
  • Notice, Certificate of Service, and [Proposed] Order
  • In Support
    • Memo
    • Certification of Scott D. McCoy
    • Certification of Lina Bensman
• ORDER Granting Motion (08/12/2013)

Defendants’ Motions for Partial Summary Judgment

• Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on claim for post-JONAH therapy expenses (03/26/2014)
  •  Motion includes Notice, Brief, Appendix, and Proposed Order
• Plaintiffs’ Opposition (04/29/2014)
• Defendants’ Reply (05/02/2014)
  • Statement of Undisputed Material Facts in support of Reply
• MOTIONS HEARING held May 9, 2014.  [Transcript]
• Parties’ Additional briefs addressing the impact of D’Agostino v. Maldano (05/28/2014)
  • Plaintiffs
  • Defendants
• ORDER and OPINION denying Motion (06/06/2014)

• Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on claims by Plaintiffs C.Levin, B.Unger, and S.Bruck for lack of standing (08/06/2014)
  • Motion includes Notice, Brief, Statement of Undisputed Material Facts, Certification of C. LiMandri with Appendix, and Proposed Order
• Plaintiffs’ Opposition (08/26/2014)
  • Includes Notice, Brief, Certifications of L. Bensman, C. Levin, B. Unger, S.Bruck, and B. Greenman
  • Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendants’ Statement of Undisputed Material Facts (09/02/2014)
• Defendants’ Reply (08/29/2014)
  • Certification of Charles S. LiMandri in support
• MOTION HEARING held September 8, 2014.  [Transcript]
• ORDER Granting as to Sheldon Bruck, Denying as to Benjamin Unger and Chaim Levin (09/08/2014)

Parties’ Motion and Cross-Motion for Partial Summary Judgment

• Plaintiffs’ Motion (11/21/2014)
  • Brief
  • Statement of undisputed material facts
  • Certification of Lina Bensman
  • Certification of Thomas S. Kessler
• Defendants’ Opposition (12/19/2014)
  • Brief
  • Response to Plaintiffs’ statement of undisputed material facts
  • Certification of Paul M. Jonna
• Plaintiffs’ Reply (01/09/2015)
  • Brief
  • Certification of Lina Bensman
  • Certification of Thomas S. Kessler
  • Certificate of Service

• Defendants’ Cross-Motion (11/25/2014)
  • Brief  67-1
  • Statement of Un 67-2
  • Certification of Paul M. Jonna 67-3
• Plaintiffs’ Opposition (12/19/2014)
  • Brief  67A-1
  • Response to Defendants’ statement of undisputed material facts   67A-2
  • Certification of Lina Bensman 67A-3
  • Certification of Paul M. Kessler
• Defendants’ Reply (01/09/2015)
  • Memo 67B

• MOTION HEARING held February 5, 2015.  [Transcript]
• ORDER and OPINION (02/10/2015)
  • Granting in part Plaintiffs’ Motion
  • Denying Defendants’ Cross-Motion