5th Cir. 16-60477 Case History

Barber v. Bryant
No. 16-60477, Docket

Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Panel: Judges Jerry E. Smith, Jennifer Walker Elrod, and Catharina Haynes

Appealed from :

• Barber v. Bryant (S.D. Miss., No.3:16-cv-00417)
• Campaign for Southern Equality v. Bryant (S.D. Miss., No.3:16-cv-00442)
  • Opinion and Order (06/30/2016)
    • preliminary injunction granted
  • Notice of Appeal [in Barber] (07/07/2016)
  • Bryant Notice of Appeal [in CSE](07/07/2016)
  • Davis Notice of Appeal  [in CSE] (07/08/2016)

Related Case

 Campaign for Southern Equality v. Bryant (5th Circ, No. 16-60478); Docket; Consolidated with this appeal [Case History and Docket under construction]

OPINION

• Published Opinion Jerry E. Smith, Circuit Judge (06/22/2017)
  • The preliminary injunction is reversed, and a judgment of dismissal for want of jurisdiction is rendered.
  • Judgment

BRIEFS ON THE MERITS

• Appellants’ Brief and Record Excerpts (10/26/2016)
• Appellees’ Briefs (12/16/2016)
  • Barber Plaintiffs
  • CSE Plaintiffs
    • Citation of Supplemental Authority (04/02/2017)
• Appellants’ Reply Brief (01/13/2017)
• CSE Plaintiffs’ Sur Reply (02/21/2017) [See opposed motion, order granting permission to file]

Amicus Briefs in support of Defendants-Appellants and reversal

• NC Values Coalition and Life, Liberty and Law Foundation (11/01/2016)
• Foundation for Moral Law (11/02/2016)
• Christian Legal Society and National Assn of Evangelicals  (11/02/2016)
• State of Texas, et al.  (11/02/2016)

Amicus Briefs in support of Plaintiffs-Appellees and affirmance

• Church-State Scholars (12/22/2016)
• Scholars Who Study the LGBT Population (12/22/2016)
• Sanderson Farms, et al. (12/23/2016)
• Gay Men’s Health Crisis, et al. (12/23/2016)
• The Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Mississippi, et al. (12/23/2016)
• Companies Opposed to H.B. 1523 (12/23/2016)
• Anti-Defamation League, et al. (12/23/2016)
• GLAD, NCLR, and ACLU (12/23/2016)
• LGBT Youth in Mississippi, et al. (01/05/2017); Redacted by permission

ORAL ARGUMENT

• Oral argument held Monday April 3, 2017 at 3:00 pm
• AUDIO
• Calendar
  • Before Judges Jerry E. Smith, Jennifer Walker Elrod, and Catharina Haynes
  •  United States Courthouse, Room C-216
    1205 Texas Avenue
    Lubbock, Texas

• Presenting Argument (45 minutes per side)
  • Jonathan F. Mitchell, for Appellants
  • Roberta A. Kaplan, for Appellees CSE Plaintiffs (23 minutes)
  • Robert Bruce McDuff, for Appellees Barber Plaintiffs (22 minutes)

STAY PENDING APPEAL, EXPEDITED APPEAL, CONSOLIDATION  (Denied, Denied, Granted)

• Motions to stay preliminary injunction pending appeal, expedite appeal, and consolidate this appeal with CSE v. Bryant, No. 16-60478
  • Bryant Motion and Exhibits in Support  (07/11/2016)
  • Davis Motion (07/13/2016)
• Oppositions to Motions (07/25/2016)
  • Barber Plaintiffs
  • CSE Plaintiffs filed in 16-60478
• Bryant and Davis Joint Reply (08/04/2016)

• ORDER (08/12/2016) Before Judges Dennis, Haynes, and Graves
• James E. Graves, Jr., Circuit Judge:
  • Motion for stay pending appeal is DENIED
  • Motion to expedite this appeal is DENIED
  • Motion to consolidate this case with 16-60478, Campaign for Southern Equality v. Bryant, (5th Cir. 2016) is GRANTED

CASE MANAGEMENT

• Case Docketed and Caption updated with additional appeal July 8, 2016

• Briefing Order (09/16/2016)
  • Appellants’ Briefs and Appendix due October 26, 2016
  • Appellees’ Briefs due November 28, 2016 December 16, 2016 (Extension granted 11/14/2016)
  • Reply due December 30, 2016 January 13, 2017 (Extension granted 12/29/2016)

Current through Docket # 14044194, 06/22/2017